A RESEARCH SERIES · EDITION 1

A RESEARCH SERIES · EDITION 1

The Agentic

The Agentic

The Agentic

Fine Print

Fine Print

Fine Print

Five conditions for every agent-led purchase.

Five conditions for every agent-led purchase.

Five conditions for every agent-led purchase.

The Five Conditions

The Five Conditions

The Five Conditions

Five things have to be true before an agent can be trusted to buy on someone’s behalf. Each is a condition in the fine print, and each needs the whole ecosystem to agree on it.

01

Discoverability

Can an assistant find and read my catalog?

Coming next

02

Verifiability

Who is this agent, and who backs it?

Coming next

03

Payments

Can it pay within the customer’s limits?

Coming next

04

Interoperability

Do agents and networks share a protocol?

Coming next

05

Accountability

Did the order match what was asked?

Edition 1 · Out now

EDITION 1

Accountability

Accountability

Accountability

in Agentic Commerce

in Agentic Commerce

in Agentic Commerce

A comprehensive study of regulatory readiness in Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia, the Philippines, Thailand and India, using the rules as they stood on 8 September 2026. It follows one purchase through each market and separates three ways it can fail: someone compromises the agent, the agent goes beyond its instructions, or the agent makes an execution error.

Free Download

Read the Full Paper

Read the Full Paper

Key Insights

Key Insights

Key Insights

The research

0 of 6

0 of 6

0 of 6

No market says who pays when an agent goes beyond its instructions.

A valid card or account credential proves a payment was allowed. It does not prove the customer wanted what the agent bought.

The research

4 vs 0

4 vs 0

4 vs 0

The rules are clearer on theft than on mistakes.

In 4 of 6 markets, rules on unauthorized payments reach a hacked agent. None clearly settles an agent’s own error: a wrong payee, a wrong amount, or paying twice.

The research

Stalled

Stalled

Stalled

Unclear liability keeps a human in every step.

If nobody knows who pays for an agent’s mistake, banks and merchants will ask the customer to approve every purchase. That defeats the point of having an agent.

The research

6 markets

6 markets

6 markets

No single market leads.

Malaysia is strongest on unauthorized payments, the Philippines gives customers most room for their own mistakes, and India leads on the right to reverse a transaction.

The research

1 of 6

1 of 6

1 of 6

Naming software in a rule is not permission to pay.

India is the only market whose payment rail names software, through UPI Circle’s “AI Profiles”, yet whether an agent may pay on its own is unresolved. Singapore’s agent guidance is voluntary.

Pine Labs perspective

2 → 4

2 → 4

2 → 4

Every purchase now has four parties, not two.

The customer, their agent, the business and its agent. When something goes wrong, all four need one shared record of what was asked, and an agreed answer on who pays.

Research findings are the author’s proposed readings of public rules in Singapore, Malaysia, Indonesia, the Philippines, Thailand and India as of 8 September 2026.

Authors & Contributors

Authors & Contributors

Authors & Contributors

Lead author

Ben Charoenwong

Associate Professor of Finance, INSEAD

Ben researches financial regulation, corporate governance and household finance, with work published in the American Economic Review and the Journal of Financial Economics. He was previously at the National University of Singapore and holds a Ph.D. in Finance from the University of Chicago Booth School of Business.

Perspective

Vijeth Pandit

Chief Product Officer, Pine Labs

Vijeth Pandit is the Chief Product Officer at Pine Labs, where he leads product and design across Pine Labs Payments, and Setu. With nearly two decades of experience in core product management, Vijeth has built and scaled high-impact products across telecom, retail, healthtech, edtech, voicetech, and fintech. An intrapreneur at heart, he has consistently driven innovation within organizations and has worked across mobile, web, and hardware products.

Perspective

Sanjeev Kumar

Chief Technology Officer, Pine Labs

Sanjeev Kumar is the Chief Technology Officer at Pine Labs, where he leads technology strategy for the company’s Digital Infrastructure and Transaction Platform. An IIT Kharagpur graduate in Engineering and a fintech technology leader with over two decades of experience, Sanjeev has been instrumental in shaping Pine Labs’ evolution from a payments-focused company into a multi-product fintech ecosystem.

Independent research supported by Pine Labs. The analysis and findings in the research section are the author’s own. Rules as of 8 September 2026. © 2026 Pine Labs.